Oldfeller--FSO
Serious Thumper ModSquad
   
Offline

Hobby is now "concentrated neuropany"
Posts: 12686
Fayetteville, NC
Gender:
|
I would have to disagree on that point.
Ran QC calibration labs that calibrated both, clickers only went 1-2 years before requiring internal tweeking to get back to low and top range spec, often they would do one but not the other and were scrapped or re-spec'd to the zone they actually functioned well in.
(mostly they got scrapped if they were plant owned tools, the personal tools only folks got all funny about their$200 Snap On or Proto clicker wrench that wouldn't calibrate any more and we would re-spec them for them to be used only in the zone they were reliable to use if it was reasonable to do so. Or we told them to take them home, they could not come back into the shop as they were junk/nuts/useless for the range the set up man actually worked in)
Deflecting beam units remained relatively consistent and faithful unless taken way out of range (damaged) but you had to buy one that was aimed at the range you were working in for the application you were doing to get enough graduations to pass a GR&R study.
0-150 foot pounds is a bit silly for fine work -- way too broad. Get a 0-50 and a 50-100 ft pound unit and use the one that best fits what you are trying to do.
One sterling use of a broad range 0-150 beam type is detecting issues with fastener pull up (bolt stretching) on LARGE bolts. If you get a lot of bolts that stretches before hitting torque, or one that will not maintain spec torque after a half hour at rest, you can determine that with a beam unit much quicker/clearer than with a clicker unit.
Personal preference for my pocketbook is a beam unit because you can see the torque build up and you know you are almost there.
A clicker leaves you blind, and ---- was that the click? mebbe not, a little more and we'll see, nope, a little more ..... nope .....
|