SALB wrote on 09/08/12 at 20:35:22:Too many variables. Weight of the bike (power to weight ratio), weight of the rider, gearing, torque and horsepower curves all play into the equation.

That said, the weight and torque of my S40 works for me!
+1.
got to agree. Too many variables. I've had a few bikes and always prefer smaller weight bikes and always ride solo. (my wife has her own bike).
It depends on what you want to do. At one time I had a 600 Katana which is about an 70 hp bike (rear wheel HP). The thing about Katana's though, is they are heavy and big for a sport bike, which made it GREAT for a highway/interstate ride (IMO). Very smooooth. ...BUT....I hated having to turn it around in my driveway or putting it in and out of my shed, etc. It was tall , heavy and really more power then I needed for around town.
on the other end, I also once had a GZ250, which is about 20hp...but small and light...sooooo...it was great for around town and I commuted to work, mainly taking 50-55 mph parkways and such, and it was just fine. The small size and weight (and low power) made the bike scary on major highways and no interstate travel on it. BUT...for most one up riding the 20hp was enough.
My Shadow Spirit 750 stock is 35.4hp (Mine's rejetted, open air box, etc, maybe 38 rear wheel hp, don't know, and a smaller rear sprocket). In my mind it's the best for just an all around bike. The sprocket change made it highway worthy, the low end torque and size makes it a blast around town.
Anyway, it just depends on how you ride etc. The Savage seems
perfect for an around town backroad bike to me. It's not the lack of HP that makes me think it's not a good highway bike, but the low weight, brakes and suspension.