Dave wrote on 12/24/15 at 05:32:55:With a small, low HP, low torque bike you will stall the engine if you get a bit uncoordinated with the clutch and throttle.....with a torquey bike you will most likely accelerate faster than the first time rider has the skill to control
This video is pretty typical of a rider who has never ridden a bike before and is taking his first ride. They don't instantly understand how the throttle or clutch of brake works....it is a process that takes a little bit to learn. Thankfully on this one the rear wheel was in the grass and the bike spun the rear wheel and the bike didn't build up much speed. If this bike was a Savage and it had all been done on pavement where the bike got a lot of traction......it would have been a bad crash.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lbb0jCy3cp0You are a new rider, and when you get more experience and actually try and teach some first time riders.....you will get an understanding about how easily folks can get hurt on that first attempt. A low torque, low weight, low HP bike is a far safer and better teaching tool. If the person where to start out on a bike with an automatic clutch that only requires the throttle to be moved to make the bike move.....that is even better.
I took the MSF course, and, for a while I had some possible regrets for not learning this myself. The feeling kinda faded away some as we got into the more advanced stuff. I can't say for sure how I would have done it myself. I probably would have missed some concepts, to some degree; however,
I was already familiar with the nature of manual transmissions. I had driven farm tractors, and the car I drove (and still drive) was a MT car. I am somewhat mechanically inclined. I could probably have picked it up in nothing flat.
The boy in the video probably didn't have a clue as to the nature of that stuff, and while it sometimes burns our brains out to accept/comprehend this degree of ignorance,

these people just don't have a clue as to the nature of these machines and how to work them. I have to remember the first time I was introduced to a MT car. It was that old VW Rabbit Convertible 5 speed. I remember my Dad having me put it in reverse, and I think I killed the motor with the brake, not understanding how the engine and drivetrain become one. I was, I think 12 or so years old.
People who have no driving experience, much less MT experience, may blindly assume that MT's work like AT's, that gas simply means "go" and brake "stop" or something. Even AT's don't entirely work like that. MT's are perhaps more complicated, but it becomes intuitive, so that anyone that drives stick can more quickly learn to drive a motorcycle (maybe). It's just that the controls are different. The principle is approximately the same. Anyone who drives stick already knows intuitively--instinctively about the friction zone, whether he or she has ever named or tried to conceptualize it. It's just a matter of foot vs hand.
On the other hand, I seem to remember reaching for the clutch or something during the MSF course (foot vs hand conflicts), so driving a car can also get you confused as well. I even thought there was some advantage to it. I don't remember it clearly, so it's hard to say what happened. Even when driving AT, it happens. One time I remember giving Mom a jolt in her AT Outback, reaching for the clutch and, instead, hitting the brake

. Have you ever reached for the gear shift knob only to remember that you're driving automatic?

When I turn onto the road, I don't like to give a lot of throttle until I straighten, so it's not as simple as, "Give the Savage as much throttle as you want and it will work no matter what." I don't want to end up laying on the ground wondering what happened.