Dave
YaBB Moderator ModSquad
   
Offline

SuzukiSavage.com Rocks!
Posts: 18316
Camp Springs, Kentucky
Gender:
|
This "belief" has likely been passed down the generations.....I don't know that any recent testing confirms that it is still true - or why the wear occurs. Is it a lack of oil pressure, the poor clearances in a cold engine, or the unburned fuel/moisture causing issues?
Back in the old days before fuel injection, most engines were worn out at 100,000 miles. It was common to see cars and trucks on the road with blue smoke coming out the tailpipe. It was rare to see a motorcycle with high engine mileage that hadn't had a rebuild or two. Rings would wear and get too big of end gaps, cylinders would wear and get ridges at the top, valve guides would get worn....sometimes the rod bearings would wear out on the top or bottom and you would get a rod knock.
Something has changed drastically, as even economy cars can reach 200,000 miles or more and still run fine (if the body holds up). My wife's last 3 cars had more than 250,000 miles on them when they were replaced - they still ran fine but she travels alone a lot and didn't want car more than 10 years old and she replaced them. My Pontiac Vibe has 160,000 miles and still runs like new, a fellow at work has more than 300,000 miles on his little Toyota...and another lady I know has more than 350,000 miles on her Toyota 4Runner. There is a Honda ST1100 in the UK that got more than 350,000 miles on the engine, and it is not uncommon for the large touring bikes to get 100,000 miles without any engine work being done.....and Youzguyz got 160,000 miles out of a Savage engine using Valvoline and Rotella.
I think fuel injection is a big part of this extended life. Back when engines had manual or automatic chokes - the fuel mixture was likely too rich for too long after the start up, and the extra fuel likely contributed to the piston ring and cylinder wear....maybe to the valve guide wear as well. Fuel injection limits the fuel right from the first start and never allows there to be "too much" fuel.....so the oil stays where it needs to be and is not washed away by the excess fuel.
I also believe engine design has improved and materials have gotten better.
And finally....I believe modern oils are far better than was available 40 years ago - even the dino oils. If we use a "top shelf" oil in our vehicles, use a viscosity rating that the manufacturer specifies, and change the oil and filter regularly - it is very likely that none of us will ever wear out a healthy engine. In the Savage we need to use an oil with a good amount of ZDDP, we need to keep the idle speed up to provide oil flow, and we need to avoid idling the bike on the sidestand.
So if "most" of the engine wear occurs at "start up".....I believe the amount of wear is pretty minimal based on the life span of current engines and we really don't need to worry about it (there is nothing you can do about it anyhow).
"70% of all statistics are made up on the spot by 64% of people that produce false statistics 54% of the time they produce them".
|