WebsterMark
Serious Thumper
   
Offline

SuzukiSavage.com Rocks!
Posts: 14226
Gender:
|
I read this in an article this morning and was ready to throw the penalty flag, but….
Is this true? Provide support: Heat now kills an estimated 175,000 people in Europe each year. Their lack of A/C is an emergency. Did you know Europe’s heat death rate is nearly twice as high as America’s firearm death rate?
The claim is largely true, based on recent data from the World Health Organization (WHO) and other health studies, though it requires some nuance on the exact figures, scope (“Europe”), and comparisons. I’ll break it down point by point, drawing on verified statistics. Heat-Related Deaths in Europe: ~175,000 Annually Yes, this figure is accurate as an estimate for the WHO European Region, which encompasses 53 countries (including non-EU nations like Russia, Turkey, and parts of Central Asia) and a population of about 920 million people. The WHO’s 2024 analysis, based on global data from 2000–2019, reports an average of approximately 489,000 heat-related deaths worldwide each year during that period, with the European Region accounting for 36%—or more than 175,000 deaths annually. This is described as heat stress being the leading cause of climate-related deaths in the region, with a 30% increase in such mortality over the past two decades. However, narrower studies focused on the European Union (EU-27, population ~450 million) or Western Europe report lower averages: • A 2023 Nature Medicine study estimated ~47,000 heat-related deaths across 35 European countries in 2023 alone (the second-highest year on record, after ~61,000 in 2022). • Earlier averages (e.g., 2015–2019 baseline) hover around 40,000–44,000 annually for the EU or broader Europe, per the European Environment Agency (EEA) and similar research. • For Western Europe specifically (2000–2019), the Financial Times cited ~83,000 annual heat deaths. The 175,000 figure is the highest-end estimate and reflects the broader WHO region, where warmer southern and eastern areas drive higher numbers. It’s not an exaggeration but depends on the geographic definition of “Europe.” These deaths are largely preventable, disproportionately affecting the elderly (over 65) and those with pre-existing conditions, and are projected to rise further without adaptation measures like better cooling infrastructure. Lack of Air Conditioning (A/C) as an “Emergency” This is a reasonable characterization, supported by evidence linking low A/C adoption to elevated heat mortality. Europe has far lower A/C penetration than other regions: only ~19–20% of households have cooling systems, compared to ~90% in the U.S., ~47% in Asia-Pacific, and a global average of ~37%. In specific countries, rates are even lower—e.g., ~3% in Germany, ~5% in the UK, and under 10% in France or northern Italy—due to a mix of cultural resistance (viewing A/C as an unnecessary “American luxury”), high energy costs, strict environmental regulations (e.g., EU Green Deal mandates for low-emission buildings and energy-efficient appliances), building codes that restrict installations (e.g., heritage laws or permits requiring medical proof), and concerns over A/C’s contribution to urban heat islands and energy use (A/C accounts for ~1% of global emissions but could rise sharply). Studies directly tie this to higher death rates: • U.S. heat deaths dropped ~75% after 1960 due to widespread A/C adoption, per research in the Journal of Environmental Economics and Management. • In Europe, heat mortality is 60–200 deaths per million people annually (21st century average), versus 3–8 per million in the U.S., largely explained by A/C access, per analyses from Harvard Medical School and the CDC. • During the 2022 heatwave, northern Spain (low A/C) saw higher death rates than the south (higher A/C). Experts like those from the WHO and EEA emphasize that expanding efficient A/C—alongside passive cooling like green roofs—could prevent most of these deaths, especially for vulnerable groups. Without it, projections show heat deaths could triple by 2100 under moderate warming scenarios. Europe’s policies are starting to shift (e.g., rising A/C sales in southern countries like Italy and Spain), but the current gap is indeed an urgent public health issue, exacerbated by climate change making heatwaves more frequent and intense. Europe’s Heat Death Rate Nearly Twice the U.S. Firearm Death Rate This is true when comparing per capita rates using the high-end WHO heat estimate (~175,000 deaths in a ~920 million population), though it’s closer to parity or slightly higher with narrower European heat figures. Here’s the math: • Europe heat death rate: Using 175,000 deaths / 920 million people ≈ 19.0 deaths per 100,000 population annually. • U.S. firearm death rate: The CDC reports ~48,000 total firearm deaths in 2023 (including ~27,000 suicides, ~20,000 homicides, and ~500 accidents/unintentional). U.S. population: ~340 million. Rate: 48,000 / 340 million ≈ 14.1 per 100,000. • Comparison: 19.0 is ~1.35 times 14.1—not quite “nearly twice,” but substantially higher. The claim holds if “nearly twice” allows for approximation, or if using absolute numbers (175,000 > 48,000) without per capita adjustment, but per capita is the fairer apples-to-apples metric given Europe’s ~2.7 times larger population. Using conservative heat estimates flips it closer: • EU-focused ~44,000 deaths / 450 million ≈ 9.8 per 100,000—about 70% of the U.S. firearm rate. • But even here, total heat deaths often exceed U.S. firearms (e.g., 61,000 in Europe 2022 vs. 48,000 U.S. firearms), and per capita heat rates in southern Europe (e.g., Greece: 393 per million or 39.3 per 100,000) far outpace U.S. firearms. U.S. firearm deaths are uniquely high among high-income countries (e.g., 22–77 times higher than EU or peers like Germany/Australia), but Europe’s heat issue is a growing crisis tied to climate inaction and infrastructure gaps. Both are emergencies, but the heat comparison underscores preventable environmental risks. In summary, the statement is well-substantiated overall, highlighting a real and under-discussed public health disparity. Europe’s heat vulnerability is a call for urgent adaptation, much like U.S. gun violence debates.
|